Should I Sell My Mortgage Note or Keep Collecting?

You're getting a payment every month on property you sold. Somebody has offered to buy those payments for a lump sum. Which is better?

There's no universal answer, but there is a way to think about it that gets most people to a decision in about twenty minutes.

Why the offer is less than the balance

Start here, because this is the sticking point for almost everyone.

Say you're owed $80,000 over the next fifteen years. An offer comes in well under that, and it feels like a lowball. It usually isn't. Two things create the gap:

• Time. A dollar arriving in 2041 is worth less than a dollar today. Every investment is priced this way, including the one your buyer made when they bought your house.
• Risk. Whoever buys the note takes on the chance that the buyer stops paying, that the property declines, that taxes go unpaid, that a foreclosure becomes necessary. You're handing off that risk along with the income.

The gap is the price of certainty today instead of possibility spread over years.

Reasons to keep collecting

• The interest rate is good. If your note is at 8% or 9% and the buyer pays like clockwork, that's a solid return that's hard to replace.
• You don't need the money. If there's no specific use for a lump sum, cash sitting in an account earning little isn't an upgrade.
• The income is useful as income. Some people genuinely rely on that monthly amount, and replacing it is harder than it looks.
• The buyer is rock solid. Long payment history, big down payment, lives in the house, takes care of it.

Reasons to sell

• You have a use for the money now. A roof, medical bills, paying off higher-interest debt, a business opportunity, tuition. Money that solves a problem today often beats money that trickles in.
• The management is wearing on you. Chasing late payments, tracking insurance, watching the tax rolls, handling the escrow — it's not nothing, especially as people get older.
• You're carrying real risk. One buyer, one property, one income stream. If that buyer stops paying, you're the one who has to deal with it.
• An estate needs to be divided. Cash splits cleanly among heirs. A monthly payment stream does not.
• The note has weaknesses. A low down payment, a shaky payment record, a property that's deteriorating — these get worse with time, not better. The note is usually worth more today than it will be.

The middle option nobody mentions

Most people believe it's all or nothing. It isn't.

In a partial sale, you sell a set number of payments — say the next sixty — and keep everything after that. You get a lump sum now, and when those sixty payments have been collected, the note comes back to you and the buyer starts paying you again.

This is often the best answer for someone who needs $25,000 for a specific purpose but doesn't want to give up a good long-term income stream. You take only as much as you need and keep the rest.

Four questions that usually settle it

1. What would you do with the money? If there's a clear answer — pay off a 22% credit card, fix the roof before it fails — selling usually wins. If the answer is "put it in savings," it usually doesn't.
2. How would you feel if the buyer stopped paying next year? If that would be a serious problem for you, you're carrying more risk than you want.
3. Do you want to be doing this in ten years? Notes run a long time. Ask whether you want that job at that age.
4. Is anyone else involved? Spouse, siblings, heirs. Better to have that conversation now than after papers are signed.

Get the number before you decide

You can't weigh any of this against an offer you haven't seen. A quote is free, it commits you to nothing, and it turns an abstract question into a concrete one — and we'll show you the full sale and the partial side by side.

And if we think holding is the better move for you, we'll say so. We'd rather be the person you call in three years than talk you into something today.

One note: this is general information, not financial or tax advice. Selling a note can have tax consequences that depend on your basis and how the original sale was structured. Talk to a tax preparer before you sign anything.

Written by Smith Washington Jr., founder of DeedBrook, Lake Charles, Louisiana.

Read next: What Is a Bond for Deed in Louisiana?

← All articles